Internet tobacco case may gut state laws
The U.S. Supreme Court has heard argument in a case that could affect dozens of state laws regulating Internet sales of tobacco or any dangerous product.
The justices heard argument Wednesday on the narrow issue of whether a federal law, the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act of 1994, pre-empts a 2003 Maine law that attempts to ban the Internet sale of tobacco products to teenagers.
The federal law is designed to ensure all transporters of goods nationwide face the same regulations, whether shipped by ground or by air. Congress specifically said the law trumped state regulations.
Maine Deputy Attorney General Paul Stern told the justices states enacted the laws because the federal government, in its failure to act, left a "regulatory void," Stateline.org reported. Justice Antonin Scalia retorted, "Maybe Congress wanted a regulatory void."
A federal judge and a federal appeals court ruled the federal law pre-empts the state law, which requires verification by sellers and transporters of the age of those receiving tobacco products.
Transporters of goods, such as truckers and delivery companies, say a Supreme Court ruling upholding those lower-court decisions would prevent the states from enacting a patchwork of regulations that would be impossible to follow.
A decision in the case should come before the end of June, when the term ends.
(Rowe vs. New Hampshire Motor Transport Assn., 06-457) // Copyright 2007 by United Press International
-
Related News
- The Moldovan Supreme Judicial Council appointed new chairman of the Supreme Court
- Moldovan Justice Minister on the dismissal of the Supreme court's chairman
- UPDATE: The bomb alert at the Moldovan Supreme Court was false
- Moldova's Communists: Dismissal of the Supreme Court's chairman was illegal!
- California must release prisoners, Supreme Court rules
- Afghan AG calls for annulment of election results
- US supreme court considers immigration law
- US Supreme Court considers major gun case
- Moldovan Communists prevent the dismissal of Supreme Court of Justice head
- Louis O’Neill: Stiffening Moldova's judiciary
- 10 most important world events of 2005
- The rise and fall of Saddam Hussein
- Iraq: Saddam Hussein and another ex-senior officials sentenced to death by hanging
- Analysis: Black Sea Rivalry
- Report: Saddam Hussein has been executed
- On 31 August Moldova celebrates the Language Day
- Sexual humiliation and torture of female protesters reported
- Saddam Hussein handed over to Iraqi authorities, say lawyers
- Saddam Hussein's execution could be within next 48-36 hours
- Deadly blast at checkpoint near Peshawar